A brief introduction to conspiracy theory
Definitions
The field of conspiracy theory is a bit confused because not
all the relevant definitions have been standardized. Let us begin with conspiracy,
which is a secret agreement to perform an illegal act. Conspiracy is the nominal
version of the verb conspire (literally to breathe together),
which means to join in a secret agreement to perform an illegal act. The people
joining together are the conspirators; the people invoking the conspiracy
are the conspiracists. Sometimes the word conspiratorialist is
used in place of conspiracist, but it isn't a real word and just confuses
things. It should be dropped from the vocabulary. Its root, conspiratorial,
means relating to a conspiracy, as in "The planners displayed
conspiratorial tendencies." It is sometimes used to refer to people who
invoke conspiracies, but this is wrong also.
The big problem is that conspiracy theory is used in
two different ways. The first is as a conspiracy theory, which refers to
to an explanation that invokes a conspiracy. Although some authors say that the
invoked conspiracy is nonexistent, I think it is more appropriate for most cases
to say that the conspiracy is unproven. The second use of conspiracy theory
is generic, referring to the act of appealing to, or the tendency to appeal to,
undocumented conspiracy (or conspiracies) and continuing to appeal to it (or
them) for years to centuries without documentation. Unfortunately, this generic
use is seldom defined—readers have to figure it
out for themselves.
We might also note that the theory in conspiracy
theory is used incorrectly. At least in the scientific world, a theory is is
an advanced stage of explanation, an idea that was first proposed
as a hypothesis, then rose to the level of working hypothesis, and then survived
enough tests to ultimately be taken very seriously and regarded as the best
explanation. A conspiracy theory usually shares none of these characteristics.
By its very nature, it is undocumentable, and hence represents the earliest
stage of explanation. It should probably be called a conspiracy hypothesis.
But even this term is too strong, because it is an idea that has failed the test
of finding concrete evidence for it. Whatever term is appropriate, it is not
conspiracy theory.
What conspiracy theories offer their practitioners
Very briefly stated, conspiracy theories offer their
practitioners at least these several advantages:
What generates conspiracy theories?
Here there are a great variety of answers.